As MTG proxies grow in popularity, so do the questions around their legality and ethics. Can you use proxies at your local game store? Are they allowed in Commander games? And most importantly—how can you use them responsibly without crossing the line into counterfeit territory?
At MythicBlackCore, we believe in clear, honest answers. Proxies, when used ethically and with consent from your playgroup, are not only acceptable—they’re one of the most empowering tools a Magic player can use.
What Are MTG Proxies, Really?
A Magic: The Gathering proxy is a substitute for an official card—usually printed to stand in for expensive, out-of-print, or test-worthy cards. Proxies are not fake cards meant to fool collectors. Instead, they’re openly used in casual formats, playtesting environments, or Cube drafts.
At MythicBlackCore, our proxies are clearly distinguishable from official cards, often featuring custom artwork or unique design elements. They’re made for players, not profit scammers.
Are MTG Proxies Legal?
When it comes to tournament legality, the answer is simple: no, proxies are not allowed in official Magic: The Gathering events sanctioned by Wizards of the Coast. However, the legality of proxies in environments is left up to the people at the table. Commander pods, kitchen table games, Cube drafts, and playtesting groups often allow—and even encourage—proxy use to keep the game inclusive and affordable.
So, while you can’t use proxies at a Grand Prix or Friday Night Magic, you can absolutely use them in home games—as long as everyone agrees.
Why Use Proxies Ethically?
The biggest concern around proxies is counterfeiting. No one wants to be scammed with fake cards sold as real. That’s why MythicBlackCore is committed to transparency. All of our MTG proxies are designed to be easily identified and never intended to pass as authentic cards. We stand firmly against counterfeiters and prioritize player trust in everything we do.
Proxies become unethical only when they’re used to deceive—either by entering sanctioned play or selling them dishonestly. Used correctly, however, proxies can actually protect the game. They allow new players to participate, collectors to preserve their cards, and deck-builders to experiment freely.
When Should You Use MTG Proxies?
You should consider using MTG proxies when:
- You’re testing a new deck and want to avoid buying expensive cards until you’re confident.
- You want to preserve high-value originals and play with proxies instead.
- You’re playing in a proxy-friendly Commander or Cube group.
- You’re introducing a new player who can’t afford a full deck yet.
In all of these cases, proxies help the game grow and stay fun. Many players buy MTG proxy cards from MythicBlackCore specifically for these reasons—because we provide a trusted, ethical way to enjoy Magic without the financial stress.
Final Thoughts
So, are MTG proxies legal? Not in official tournaments. But are they ethical, smart, and often necessary? Absolutely—especially when used with honesty and consent.
At MythicBlackCore, we advocate for ethical proxying. Our proxies are designed for clarity, style, and fair use—not for deception. When you choose to buy MTG proxy cards from us, you're choosing a brand that respects both the game and the players who love it.
Proxies aren’t a threat to Magic—they’re part of its evolution. Use them wisely, use them proudly, and let MythicBlackCore help you do it right.
Comments